Pupils who fall behind
"When I looked at texts, they were just a jumble of words. Numbers were a bit better, but they weren’t easy either. I couldn’t find any flow in them," he recalls.
At night, he would lie in bed, dreading the next school day, convinced that he wouldn’t be able to achieve anything. He couldn’t grasp the connections in his schoolbooks, so eventually, he stopped opening them altogether. Instead, he talked. A lot.
Young Kenneth was a constant challenge for the teachers at Fjell Middle School, just outside Bergen, as he himself admits. They didn’t know what to do with him.
The teachers tried their best: they provided special education, extra reading practice, and ongoing support. But nothing seemed to help.
Then, three unexpected things became his saving grace:
The sea.
The janitor.
Two sentences his teacher once said about him.
How do we create an educational system that supports and stimulates all children so they can participate at an equal footing in society?
This question is at the heart of the European research project PIONEERED involving researchers from nine different countries. Amongst them are Solvejg Jobst and Ivan Tokheim from Western Norway University of Applied Sciences.
The researchers are examining alternative practices in the school system—innovative teaching methods designed to help pupils who struggle with traditional education.
Their research aims to provide recommendations to national authorities in the nine countries on how all children can receive the support and services they need, both in their education and personal development.
Students struggle in many different ways. Some have learning disabilities. Others have developed challenging behaviors—becoming violent or disruptive. Still others have withdrawn completely into themselves, struggling mentally, with some even experiencing suicidal thoughts. A number of them come from unstable homes.
The variations are vast, but they all have one thing in common:
"They’ve lost their sense of agency. These children and youngsters have failed in school for so long that they’ve lost faith in themselves. As a result, they can no longer take responsibility for themselves or make good decisions," says Ivan Tokheim.
"But this is something we can address, even in the most challenging cases."
The Boy Who Loved the Sea
One of the alternative educational programs that Jobst and Tokheim have researched, along with several colleagues, is called TAM. The Norwegian acronym stands for "Safety, Responsibility, and Mastery," and it has been in existence for nearly 26 years.
Children and young people from 5th to 10th grade in the Sotra schools can apply to participate in this program. Currently, 30 pupils are part of the project.
Once a week, they go on placements and work in small groups, engaging in maritime activities like fishing, taking the boat operator’s exam, and cleaning up beaches.
The man who started this program a quarter of a century ago is Kenneth Bruvik.
"I grew up by the sea. Down by the shore, I felt at home, much more than anywhere else," he says.
After miserable years in middle school, he gravitated towards the sea, seeking an escape from school. He first worked for a while on a purse seiner, then spent a few years at a mechanical workshop. These were happy years—working manually, doing practical tasks.
He, who had mostly felt useless throughout his school years, now realized that he was good at something. Very good. If something needed fixing, Bruvik would most likely find a way to fix it.
But he had a dream that went beyond just fixing things. He wanted to start a program for children and youngsters to engage them with the sea and nature, allowing them to experience the same joy he had. So, he approached The Norweigan Association of Hunters and Anglers and asked if they would join him. They did.
"In the beginning, we took school classes outdoors. But soon, we saw that some of the youngsters needed something extra. So, we started targeting the program towards them."
Hidden in Hoodies
What does it really mean to go to school year after year, feeling like you can’t accomplish anything?
"It’s like getting a slap in the face every single day. Eventually, I no longer wanted to go to school,” says Kenneth Bruvik.
He feels an affinity to many of those he meets through TAM.
"I know what it feels like to have lost hope."
Many of those who come to TAM, mostly boys, prefer to wear large hoodies. At first, they tend to hide inside of them, often pulling the hood down so far over their faces that others can barely see their mouths.
They seek refuge in this way because they expect nothing good from the world. What do you do, then, in order to reach them?
I recognize the darkness they’re in.
When I see it, I know I have a job to do.
“I start with the mouth, since that’s all I can see," says Bruvik.
"First, I use some approaches to get movement in the lower part of their faces. As soon as there’s sound in the mouth, the hood often starts to lift. Then I see a pair of eyes. After a while, there may be some interaction between the mouth and the eyes. A smile may come along with a sparkle in the eyes. Then, small embers and sparks ignite."
This process of coaxing a young person out of their hoodie can take a long time—sometimes as much as a year. But it’s worth it for Kenneth Bruvik. Seeing those embers and sparks is what he lives for.
The Legacy of the Janitor
We have to go back to the janitor at Fjell Middle School. Even though school was a torment for young Kenneth, this man was a major bright spot. He made a decisive difference for this boy that no one else knew what to do with.
Bruvik doesn’t know how it happened—whether the principal suggested it or if the janitor took the initiative on his own. Either way, it was a wise move.
Sometimes Kenneth was allowed to leave the classroom to accompany the janitor and do practical tasks around the school.
This way, the young boy experienced the joy of using his hands.
Suddenly, things weren’t so difficult anymore—he saw that he was able to contribute in valuable ways.
Now he uses this method with the young people in TAM.
"I have yet to meet a person who doesn’t know how to do something practical," says Bruvik.
"And the moment you do a piece of practical work, there is beauty in it: you get a visual experience of accomplishing something. That means a lot. That’s why I’m always quick to give pupils a practical task. Then I can start to look for their strengths. What do they like, what are they good at?"
The Chordal Triad of Agency
In exploring the educational practices in TAM, Ivan Tokheim and his colleagues have made use of the sociological concept of "agency" to understand what happens with the participants in the program.
The hypothesis of "The Chordal Triad of Agency" was developed by researchers Emirbayer and Mische in 1998. Tokheim has translated this as "Handlekraftas treklang" (The Threefold Chord of Agency).
You can think of it as agency having three different elements or tones, like a chord.
The first tone is about creating safe boundaries, as no one can act well in the world without feeling safe.
This safe environment is created in TAM by being calmly present as adults and by giving tasks that the young people can master.
The threshold for feeling mastery is low, and they receive recognition and respect from day one. They also work in small groups with many adults present. This way, they get a completely different level of support and attention than in the classroom.
The second tone is about believing in the future. Pupils at risk of dropping out of school have usually lost faith that their future can be any good. But by accomplishing more and more tasks in TAM and receiving positive feedback, they regain confidence in themselves.
Many return to their regular school after their placement day and proudly talk about what they’ve done by the sea. Some even get better grades in their subjects, despite missing some regular school hours.
A new way of being present here and now
When these two tones resonate together—safe boundaries and a belief in the future—a third tone emerges: a new way of seeing the present. When you feel safe and can envision a future for yourself, you gain a sense of direction, a compass for your own life.
Thus, you can look more closely at what you are doing here and now and develop a healthy sense of judgment around it. You naturally start to evaluate your actions and choose what you believe will help you move forward. This way, you become equipped to make better choices.
"TAM hasn’t had this framework in mind, but still, they’ve intuitively worked with exactly these three steps to build up agency in young people. I believe that’s why the program has been such an enormous success," says Tokheim.
What the Teacher Said
Being seen for who you are—it may sound simple. But this is the essence of what it takes for a person to thrive. The janitor made a big difference. So did the homeroom teacher. Bruvik still remembers the words he once said to his mother, while little Kenneth was listening: "I’m not worried about Kenneth. He’ll manage."
It’s incredible how much it means—having someone say they believe in you.
I carry those words with me even now, forty years later.
Now he makes sure to do the same for his own students. If they’ve done a task well, he wants them to know.
They really need that affirming gaze. Few of them have had much experience of being seen in that way.
"On our way to lunch, or in another moment away from the rest of the group, I might say to that person: ‘You know, what you did this morning was good. Think a bit about the good thing you did.’"
The path to that good action, even if it was simple, has often been very long. The children Bruvik works with have been considered lost by those around them.
One of them greeted him on the first day with the words: "I can smash your face in." Bruvik responded that both he and the other adults were there to help him.
The same boy once nearly attacked another after getting poked in the eye during a playful fight. Bruvik held him back in his arms. He held on steadily, but also loosened his grip a bit, so the boy wouldn’t feel trapped.
When the boy tried to lash out again with his fist raised, Bruvik held him back. In the end, he took the big boy down onto his lap, sitting with him for a while until he calmed down.
Then he asked, "What do you need from an adult now?" The boy replied, "Exactly what you gave me."
"Inside of them, there´s usually just a scared little child. I know that. That’s why I’ve never been afraid of any of my pupils."
Everyone Should Have This Opportunity
Researchers Ivan Tokheim and Solvejg Jobst, together with their colleagues Espen Dyngeland, Maria Kråkenes and Jan Skrobanek, have drawn a clear conclusion after their research on TAM: A similar alternative should be available at all Norwegian schools. This is necessary if they are to succeed with providing inclusion and personal development – and in order for all children to be equipped to manage their lives.
TAM has one central thing in common with several other pioneering practices in the European educational system: The recognition of the child is at the core of them.
Here lies the key to making educational systems across Europe fairer and more inclusive.
"Our clear recommendation is that we must start coordinating Norwegian programs of this kind to strengthen them. Maybe we can start in Western Norway. The goal should be to make this an integrated part of the Norwegian school system,” says Solvejg Jobst.
Already today, there are many similar programs in Norwegian elementary schools. Some are privately run and volunteer-based. Others are municipal initiatives. What they have in common is that students are often taken away from the school to another location where they work on practical tasks.
These programs are vulnerable, depending as they do on political support or local enthusiasts to continue.
A disadvantage is also that they are expensive. At TAM, the adult-to-pupil ratio is much higher than at school. They depend on equipment such as boats, fuel, ropes, and fishing gear.
But Bruvik has no doubt that it’s worth the investment:
"If you consider a perspective from cradle to grave, a life that goes off track is incredibly costly. It easily costs thirty million paid by the community. I’m convinced that we save society enormous sums by helping these pupils become contributing members instead," he says.
No Walls, No Ceilings
Many times through the years, Bruvik has felt an urge to take pupils under his wing and bring them home with him.
"Some of them, but not all, have parents who struggle. Then it gets passed on. I want to break that cycle," he says.
He doesn’t think it’s just the way they approach children that makes a difference. The surroundings also matter a great deal—just getting outside.
In those young people who are completely closed off, he sees how being in nature helps open them up.
When they are in the forest or by the sea, something changes inside of them. The pace of their breath slows down. Their bodies become calmer.
I don’t have a ceiling, nor walls, nor a floor. I have nature. You don’t get that stifling feeling here that you sometimes get inside a classroom or an office.
"There are beautiful sunrises with a red hue and some wind. At other times, there’s a lot of wind and big waves. The beauty of it, everything that changes from day to day - this affects the kids subtly, nudging them in a slightly different direction. And that small difference can mean so much."
Some of the young people become so calm that they fall asleep. They can sit in the boat and sleep throughout an entire day.
"It’s not about laziness," says Bruvik, "but rather, that they were completely exhausted before they came to me. Their shoulders were tense, their bodies full of stress. They’ve struggled so much in their daily lives. Now, at last, they can they relax."
When they calm down to such an extent that they fall asleep, it’s a sign that they’re beginning to feel like part of the community, Bruvik believes. And making sure these children feel a deep sense of belonging is his main goal.
When people feel valued, they don’t cause trouble. It’s that simple.
Written by Katrine Sele
Photos: Katrine Sele, Kenneth Bruvik, Siri Helena Halvorsen and Shutterstock
This article is published at sciencenorway.no